English
Hobbits & Wizards –The Amazon 1-Click Reexamination –
Various stories began appearing yesterday noting the recent termination of the ex parte reexamination Amazon’s famous “1 – click patent” (USP 5,960,411). This patent was the subject of a patent dispute between Amazon.com and Barnes & Noble.com. As most recall, B&N was subject to a preliminary injunction during the 1999 holiday season. The suit was settled in 2002, terms of the settlement remain confidential. Amazon appears to have been fairly successful in licensing the patent thereafter.
In 2006, a New Zealand actor appearing in such films as Lord of the Rings, decided to go on a quest to invalidate the 1- click patent (I’m picturing Frodo, I don’t know about you) requesting ex parte reexamination of all claims. The request for reexamination was granted with respect to the claims of the patent (1-26). Claims 6-10 recited a shopping cart component and were confirmed patentable over the submitted art of the request.
Not surprisingly, the shopping cart feature of the confirmed claims was later introduced by Amazon into rejected claims 1-5 and 11-26 by amendment. This amendment was submitted to the USPTO in 2007. It is unclear why the USPTO took so long to terminate the reexamination, however, the termination is not the least bit surprising as the writing has been on the wall for several years now. So, one would expect that the conclusion of this reexamination would be rather uneventful right?
Wrong
Yesterday the typical Read the rest of this entry »
