English
Microsoft Files Another Patent Reexamination Request Against i4i
The seemingly never ending Microsoft v. i4i dispute continued on to the doorstep of the Supreme Court last week. In 2009, Microsoft was found to have infringed i4i’s 5,787,449 patent, which allegedly claims certain XML translation features of Microsoft Word. An appeal to the CAFC earlier this year was unsuccessful. On August 27th, Microsoft filed a petition for certiorari questioning the lower court’s use of the clear and convincing standard relative to art not before the USPTO during prosecution of the original patent application.
Along the way, Microsoft sought ex parte reexamination of the ‘449 Patent (90/010,347), largely as an afterthought to hedge against a willfulness finding. Not surprisingly, since the request ignored definitions of certain claim terms of the ‘449 Patent specification, the reexamination attempt was unsuccessful and all claims exited reexamination in July of this year. With the trail now over, and appeal options exhausted (save the last ditch appeal to the Supreme Court), it would seem that at least the patent reexamination chapter of this saga was complete.
Yet, as reported by IPWatchdog yesterday, Microsoft has filed a second request for ex parte reexamination of the ‘449 patent (90/011,198) just last Tuesday. So, what exactly is Microsoft hoping to accomplish? Read the rest of this entry »
